Handling Double Bookings, Cancellations, and Refund Requests

Stay Calm & Host On: My Approach to Double Bookings and Cancellations

There's a particular sinking feeling that every host knows. It's that moment you look at your calendar and see two different names for the same set of dates. Your stomach drops. Especially now, as we're heading into the busy Thanksgiving and holiday season, a double booking or a last-minute cancellation can feel like a major catastrophe.

But here's the thing: it happens. To the most organized, experienced hosts out there. The key isn't to avoid these issues forever (that's impossible), but to have a solid plan in place so you can handle them with grace and professionalism. Over the years, I've developed a system that keeps my stress levels down and my guest reviews positive. Here’s what I do.

First, Let's Tackle the Dreaded Double Booking

Okay, take a deep breath. Panicking won’t sync your calendars. The moment you spot the overlap, it's time to act quickly and transparently.

Step 1: Communicate Immediately

Don't wait, hoping one of them will cancel. I immediately reach out to the guest who booked second. I start with a sincere apology and take full responsibility, even if it was a tech glitch. Never blame the platform or the guest. A simple, "Hi [Guest Name], I am so incredibly sorry, but I've had a technical error with my calendar and have a pre-existing booking for your dates" works well.

Step 2: Be the Solution

After you've apologized, you need to offer a solution. Don't just leave them hanging. I usually offer to help them find a comparable alternative in the area, sometimes even calling a few fellow hosts I know. As a gesture of goodwill for the major inconvenience, I always offer them a significant discount on a future stay. It shows you care and helps soften the blow, protecting your reputation.

Handling Cancellations with Grace

Cancellations are just part of the rental business. While they can mess with your income projections, how you handle them says a lot about you as a host.

Stick to Your Policy

Your cancellation policy is your best friend. It sets clear expectations for both you and your guests. Whether you choose a flexible, moderate, or strict policy, it's there for a reason. In most cases, I stand by it politely but firmly. This is especially important during peak seasons when a last-minute cancellation means a real loss of income.

Know When to Be Flexible

That said, there's always a human element. If a guest cancels due to a true family emergency or illness, I try to show some compassion. Sometimes, offering a partial refund when your policy says "none" or allowing them to reschedule can earn you a loyal guest for life. It's a judgment call, but kindness often pays off in the long run.

The Refund Request Conversation

This is where things can get tricky. Guests can ask for refunds for all sorts of reasons, both during and after their stay. The key is clear, calm, and empathetic communication.

Getting the wording right is crucial in these emails. You want to be fair but also stick to your policies without sounding cold or corporate. It used to take me forever to write these responses, trying to get the tone just right. To make it easier on myself, I put together all of my go-to scripts and message templates into a handy guide. It covers everything from refund requests to check-in instructions. If you're looking to save some time and stress, you can check out my Essential Host Communication Guide over on my Etsy shop. It's been a lifesaver for me, especially during busy periods.

Prevention is the Best Medicine

As we approach the end of the year, now is a great time to do a quick audit of your systems. Double-check that your calendars are syncing correctly across all platforms. If you're listed on more than two sites, a channel manager might be worth looking into. Review your cancellation policy and make sure it still aligns with your business goals for the coming year.

Dealing with these issues is never fun, but having a clear plan makes it feel less like a crisis and more like a manageable part of the job. It helps you protect your business, your reputation, and most importantly, your peace of mind.

What are your go-to strategies for handling these tricky situations? I’d love to hear your tips and experiences in the comments below!

---

Simple Tools To Help You Win Business

Visit my shop for more host tools at ArtInScienceDesigns.Etsy.com or get your first item FREE from my LinkTree website.

AND... Follow Me on CF

#experiencematters #knowledgesharing #investor #propertymanagement #landlord #7propertiesga #airbnbhost #etsy #shorttermrentals